Back to Prosper

What Prosper Told Its School Board It Wants in the Next Superintendent

A community input report now in front of the Prosper ISD board asks for a visible, 'fresh eyes' leader who knows Texas school finance, with respondents praising the district's teachers and facilities while pressing for better substitutes, higher teacher pay and more transparency.

Xenia Yoder

July 21, 20264 min read

An empty school district board room before a meeting - illustration, Jake Team LLC
An empty school district board room before a meeting - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Prosper ISD families, teachers and students have told the district's board what they want in the next superintendent, and the answer runs to seven pages: someone highly visible, new to the district, fluent in Texas school finance, and thick-skinned enough to manage a system growing faster than its buildings.

The findings come from an executive summary dated July 15 and prepared by Impact Education Specialists, the firm running the district's search. Consultants Jennifer Settle, Kevin Worthy and Doug Williams held two days of input sessions in Prosper with central office staff, campus administrators, faculty and staff, support groups, student advisory groups, and civic and town members, and surveyed stakeholders separately.

Each session asked three questions: what the district does well, what could be improved, and what the next superintendent should be like. The report goes to the Board of Trustees as it begins interviewing candidates for the vacant post.

The profile

The summary describes an ideal candidate who "leads from the front" and becomes a regular presence on campuses rather than staying in the central office, attending academic, athletic, fine arts and special education events alike. Respondents favored an outside hire with "fresh eyes" and a track record running a large, fast-growing Texas district, backed by substantial classroom teaching experience.

They also want a working command of school finance. The report calls for a leader who can navigate tight budgets, "eliminate administrative waste," and redirect money to classrooms, while explaining the reasoning behind hard decisions.

Alongside that, respondents asked for humility and collaboration, a leader who listens to veteran staff and gathers feedback before major policy shifts, but who has, in the report's words, the "thick skin" to handle social media scrutiny and stand behind teachers.

What the district is doing right

Participants praised the district's teachers most of all, citing their commitment and the professional autonomy they are given. Facilities drew consistent compliments, including modern campuses, classroom technology and a standalone district police department that respondents said provides reassurance amid rapid growth.

The report also credits the range of programs available, from 6A athletics and fine arts to Career and Technical Education pathways for students not bound for college, and singles out early learning initiatives such as the Suzuki strings program, Hope Squad and speech pathology services.

Running through the responses is pride in what the summary calls a "small town" feel the district has kept despite explosive population growth, and a reputation the report describes as a "brand name" in North Texas.

Where they want change

Substitute teachers drew the sharpest criticism. Stakeholders faulted the quality of outsourced substitutes and called for tighter vetting so student learning is not interrupted.

Pay was the next theme. Respondents pressed for more competitive salaries and benefits to reduce burnout, specifically citing pay compression for veteran teachers, pay equity for campus paraprofessionals, protected planning time, and relief from what they described as excessive meetings and repetitive professional development. Many urged the district to examine its organizational chart, cut redundant administrative roles and move that money to campuses.

Respondents also asked for greater transparency about budgets and safety incidents, and for structures ensuring that hiring and promotions are merit-based. The report says stakeholders want to eliminate fears of retaliation and what some described as nepotism, alongside firmer student discipline and anti-bullying measures.

On special education, participants called for more staffing and oversight to ensure student plans are followed, and for stronger support for students in the academic middle.

Two other themes reflect a district growing quickly: frustration with overcrowded campuses and rezoning that families experience as reactive, and concern about screen time, with parents and staff questioning reliance on Chromebooks and video-based lessons in early grades.

What the surveys showed

In the parents and community survey, high-quality teaching and learning drew the highest score among the challenges listed, at 6.04, followed by teacher recruitment and retention at 5.26 and managing growth at 4.46. Competition and choices scored lowest at 2.62.

Among leadership traits, integrity and ethics scored highest at 6.88, ahead of strong communication skills at 5.34 and visionary leadership at 5.30. Decisiveness and adaptability scored lowest, at 2.69 and 2.85.

The vacancy

Superintendent Holly Ferguson announced her retirement on March 9 after a 28-year career in public education, 23 of them at Prosper ISD. She led the district through May 18 before transitioning to superintendent emeritus, and her career in public education formally ends January 31, 2027.

The board has not announced a timeline for naming her successor.

Sources

https://files-backend.assets.thrillshare.com/documents/asset/uploaded_file/4567/Pisd/d0200f17-6146-4c1d-9c5b-3eb0752b47df/Search-Input---Exec-Summary-7.17.26-%281%29.pdf

https://files-backend.assets.thrillshare.com/documents/asset/uploaded_file/4567/Pisd/26599e4b-9a51-4ece-b4a9-f5721faaf870/Ferguson_Retirement_Announcement.pdf

Share

Xenia Yoder

Xenia Yoder writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Prosper.

Related Stories

More in Texas

Texas

Texas Flood Response Moves Toward Cleanup and Rebuilding

Gov. Greg Abbott said state and local agencies are coordinating debris removal, infrastructure repairs and recovery assistance. The governor’s office said about 490 homes have been identified as damaged, while personnel and specialized equi

Opal FieldsJuly 21, 20261 min read